Thread: Kamara vs Mcgeady

I'd have Davis at Celtic any day.........but he's no McGeady

Originally Posted by Dubs

I'd have Davis at Celtic any day.........but he's no McGeady

You're right, Davis actually comes from the country he plays for.

Originally Posted by Rosco67

You're right, Davis actually comes from the country he plays for.

was waiting for someone to say this.

I bet you on freedoms life that if McGeady never declared for the ROI we would not be having so many threads about his talent.

Originally Posted by Aidan celt4life

paddy mccourt, zemamma riordan,stokes,o,brien,that well striker juttivewtazzzz craig conway david goodwillie there are plenty good players in the spl

not one of those players are better than mcgeady btm line m8! paddy maybe has more skill but not a better player as aiden has more to his game IMO the rest that u have said couldne lace his boots

Originally Posted by Dubs

I'd have Davis at Celtic any day.........but he's no McGeady

davis is a good player but IMO far from a great player

Originally Posted by Dubs

was waiting for someone to say this.

I bet you on freedoms life that if McGeady never declared for the ROI we would not be having so many threads about his talent.

Unsure. I really don't think many people within Celtic actually give a shite about what nationality he plays for. In fact I would bet one of my bollocks that more people are happy about his decision than unhappy.

The questioning about his talent was always going to come because he's been with us so long and in all honesty hasn't added a huge amount to his game. He still can't cross very well or have enough of his shots hit the target with any real threat. Everyone recognises he's always crowded out with players when he has the ball which would work to our advantage if his decision making was good.

Don't get me wrong, if he left we'd be left with a glaring entertainment void the likes of when Nakamura left. However, McGeady can only be progressing for so long before we have to ask where the final product is.

Edit: For the record, I was only being a bam with the nationality jibe.

Originally Posted by Dubs

was waiting for someone to say this.

I bet you on freedoms life that if McGeady never declared for the ROI we would not be having so many threads about his talent.

Gotta love that Irish chip Dubs.

Originally Posted by snidey

not one of those players are better than mcgeady btm line m8! paddy maybe has more skill but not a better player as aiden has more to his game IMO the rest that u have said couldne lace his boots

he is nae better than riordan a always thought he should have played before mcgeady so to is zemamma and the simple fact is mcgeady is overated he has 1 trick and it has been figuerd out

as for davis he is the best mildfileder in scotland at the moment

Originally Posted by Aidan celt4life

he is nae better than riordan a always thought he should have played before mcgeady so to is zemamma and the simple fact is mcgeady is overated he has 1 trick and it has been figuerd out

as for davis he is the best mildfileder in scotland at the moment

Stick t girls Aidan 'cause ye know fcuk all about players mate.

Originally Posted by sellikdaft

Stick t girls Aidan 'cause ye know fcuk all about players mate.

I don't want to agree with you but I have to on this occasion. A couple of wild claims there, young wan.